We've Become Good at Ignoring Things

I was having lunch with someone last week when our conversation took an interesting turn. We were talking about email newsletters and subscriptions. Specifically, all those newsletters we voluntarily sign up for because we're genuinely interested in what they have to say.

You know the ones. You subscribe with every intention of reading them. Maybe it's industry news, a favorite writer, or something related to a hobby, but yes, the emails start arriving. You see them, make a mental note to read them later, and move on. A few days pass, a few more emails arrive, and eventually you're staring at 147 unread messages wondering how your inbox became a second job. So you do what any reasonable person would do. Select all. Delete.

The funny thing is, you still want the information, but you never got around to reading it.

That conversation got me thinking about something we don't talk about enough in marketing. We've become incredibly good at ignoring things. Honestly, we've had to.

Between emails, notifications, advertisements, social media, and the endless stream of information competing for our attention, our brains have become remarkably efficient at deciding what deserves a closer look and what can be ignored. In the psychological world it's called selective attention, and it's our brain's ability to focus on certain information while filtering out everything else. There's also habituation, which happens when repeated exposure causes us to pay less attention. Think about the notification you barely notice anymore or the banner ad your eyes have learned to skip entirely.

Our brains aren't necessarily getting worse at paying attention; they're getting better at protecting it. That's where things get interesting for marketers.

We've spent years responding to declining attention by producing more. Think about it… more emails, more posts, more reminders. If something doesn't perform, we change the subject line, add a stronger hook, or increase the frequency. But what if the problem isn't that our messages aren't loud enough? What if we're simply contributing to the very noise we're trying to break through?

Consider those unread newsletters. They weren't necessarily bad. In fact, some were probably excellent. The problem wasn't a lack of interest; instead, it was a lack of available attention at the moment they arrived. And that's an important distinction.

We measure marketing success by whether someone opened, clicked, watched, or engaged. Those metrics matter, but they don't always tell us whether someone values what we're offering. Sometimes the timing is wrong, sometimes life is busy, and sometimes even something genuinely interesting loses the competition to the 47 other things demanding attention.

I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about how to capture attention, but increasingly, I’m more interested in how to earn it. There's a difference.

Maybe the answer isn't another email reminding someone to read the first email. Maybe it's creating something so useful, entertaining, or relevant that people actually look forward to receiving it. And maybe it's knowing when to communicate and, just as importantly, when to leave people alone. After all, the goal shouldn't be to become the loudest voice in someone's inbox or social feed. It should be to become one of the few voices they actually want to hear.

And as for those newsletters I keep deleting? I'm sure I'll get around to reading the next one. Probably… maybe.

Next
Next

Why is Everything an Experience?