Is the Algorithm Making Us Boring?

Somewhere along the way, we started confusing being relevant with being predictable. Spend a few minutes scrolling through social media, and you'll notice something interesting. The same video formats, the same trending audio, the same clever little hooks that were genuinely clever the first 400 times we saw them. Different brands, different industries, remarkably similar personalities.

It's not necessarily because marketers have run out of ideas. We've simply become very good at figuring out what works. Algorithms reward certain behaviors, so we repeat them. Before long, creativity starts looking suspiciously like compliance.

And apparently, consumers are noticing. According to Sprout Social's 2025 Index, 33% of consumers find it embarrassing when brands jump on viral trends, while roughly half say original content is what makes their favorite brands stand out. Which brings us to another interesting phenomenon: our obsession with finding a niche.

We're constantly told to narrow our focus, identify our audience, and stay in our lane. The logic makes sense. Relevance matters, and consistency helps people recognize a brand. But somewhere between defining our niche and optimizing our content, we may have forgotten something fairly important. People aren't one-dimensional. Why should brands be?

Think about the people you find most interesting. Your friend who loves fly fishing might also have an inexplicable obsession with French cooking. The accountant who spends weekends racing mountain bikes might be the funniest person at dinner. It's the unexpected layers that make people interesting, yet in the name of consistency, we often strip those layers away from brands.

A luxury real estate brand becomes nothing but beautiful homes. A restaurant becomes an endless parade of perfectly plated food. A destination becomes a collection of scenic overlooks. All perfectly appropriate, potentially effective, and after a while, I’ll say it… BORING.

Of course, niche marketing has its place. Nobody is suggesting a financial services company should suddenly start posting sourdough recipes because someone in accounting makes a fantastic loaf. But there's a difference between knowing what your brand stands for and believing that's the only thing you're allowed to talk about.

The irony is that we're living in an era when authenticity is practically a marketing requirement, yet we're simultaneously creating increasingly rigid rules about how brands should behave. Be human, we're told. Just make sure you're the exact same human every Tuesday at 10 a.m.

And perhaps that's where we've gone all wrong. An algorithm recognizes patterns, not surprises. It tells us what people responded to yesterday, but that doesn't necessarily tell us what might excite them tomorrow. When yesterday's performance becomes tomorrow's creative brief, we're essentially asking the past to predict the future. Meanwhile, the people we're trying to reach are living wonderfully complicated lives. The person researching a multimillion-dollar home might also be watching videos of goats jumping on trampolines. Both can be true, which we LOVE!

So maybe the opportunity isn't to abandon our niches, but to stop treating them like fences. A strong brand can be sophisticated and funny, informative and curious, polished and occasionally imperfect. Those contrasts aren't necessarily inconsistencies. They're personalities.

Think about it… if the ultimate goal is to connect with actual human beings, perhaps we should spend a little less time trying to satisfy a machine. The algorithm might know what people are likely to watch. But knowing what makes them stop, think, laugh, or remember you? Well, that's still a very human skill.

Next
Next

The Year-End Scramble